44 VERIFIED MATCHES
Games with New Game Plus
Every game here offers New Game Plus or a closely related replay mode, although unlock conditions and carry-over rules differ. Knowing that a second journey exists can make a first run less stressful when choices, builds or collectibles cannot all be completed together.
Do not assume that levels, equipment, quests and difficulty options all carry forward. Use the individual guide to check missables and cleanup access before deciding whether to finish optional content now or leave it for NG+.
COMPARISON VIEW
Compare replay support and first-run commitments
2 of 3 selected · choose up to three games
| Decision point | The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt | Elden Ring |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | PS5, PS4, Xbox Series, Xbox One, Switch, PC | PS5, PS4, Xbox Series, Xbox One, Switch 2, PC |
| Genre | RPG | Action RPG |
| Completion | 100–150h+ platinum | 60–100h platinum |
| Missables | Yes | Yes |
| Point of no return | Yes | Yes |
| New Game+ | Yes | Yes |
| Free roam after story | Yes | Yes |
| Manual saves | Yes | No |
| Game | Platforms | Missables | NG+ | Completion | Open |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Witcher 3: Wild HuntRPG | PS5 · PS4 · Xbox Series +3 | Yes | Yes | 100–150h+ platinum | |
| Elden RingAction RPG | PS5 · PS4 · Xbox Series +3 | Yes | Yes | 60–100h platinum | |
| Dark Souls RemasteredAction RPG | PS4 · Xbox One · Switch +1 | Yes | Yes | 70–100h platinum | |
| Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First SinAction RPG | PS4 · Xbox One · PC | Yes | Yes | 50–70h platinum | |
| Dark Souls IIIAction RPG | PS4 · Xbox One · PC | Yes | Yes | 80–120h platinum / achievements | |
| BloodborneAction RPG | PS4 | Yes | Yes | 50–75h platinum | |
| Sekiro: Shadows Die TwiceAction | PS4 · Xbox One · PC | Yes | Yes | 50–70h platinum | |
| Demon's SoulsAction RPG | PS5 | Yes | Yes | 25–30h experienced; 50h+ first-time platinum | |
| Final Fantasy VII RemakeJRPG | PS5 · PS4 · Xbox Series +2 | No | Yes | 70–100h platinum; 30–40h story | |
| Final Fantasy VII RebirthJRPG | PS5 · Xbox Series · Switch 2 +1 | No | Yes | 150–200h platinum; 40–60h story | |
| Final Fantasy X / X-2 HD RemasterJRPG | PS4 · PS3 · Xbox One +2 | Yes | Varies | 200h+ for both platinum trophies | |
| Final Fantasy XVJRPG | PS4 · Xbox One · PC | No | Yes | 40–60h platinum; 25–35h story | |
| Final Fantasy XVIJRPG | PS5 · Xbox Series · PC | Yes | Yes | 70h+ platinum; 35–45h story | |
| Persona 5 RoyalJRPG | PS5 · PS4 · Xbox Series +3 | Yes | Yes | 100h+ platinum | |
| Persona 3 ReloadJRPG | PS5 · PS4 · Xbox Series +3 | Yes | Yes | 60–80h platinum | |
| Persona 4 GoldenJRPG | PS4 · Xbox Series · Xbox One +2 | Yes | Yes | 100–150h platinum | |
| Mass Effect Legendary EditionRPG | PS4 · Xbox One · PC | Yes | Yes | 100–150h trilogy completion route | |
| StarfieldRPG | Xbox Series · PC | Yes | Yes | 75–125h achievement route | |
| Horizon Zero DawnAction RPG | PS5 · PS4 · PC | No | Yes | 50–80h platinum route | |
| Horizon Forbidden WestAction RPG | PS5 · PS4 · PC | Yes | Yes | 40–60h platinum route | |
| God of WarAction | PS4 · PC | No | Yes | 40–60h platinum route | |
| God of War RagnarökAction | PS5 · PS4 · PC | No | Yes | 40–60h platinum route | |
| Ghost of TsushimaAction / Open World | PS5 · PS4 · PC | No | Yes | 40–60h platinum route | |
| Marvel's Spider-Man RemasteredAction / Open World | PS5 · PC | No | Yes | 25–35h platinum route | |
| Marvel's Spider-Man: Miles MoralesAction / Open World | PS5 · PS4 · PC | No | Yes | 15–20h platinum route | |
| Marvel's Spider-Man 2Action / Open World | PS5 · PC | No | Yes | 25–35h platinum route | |
| The Last of Us Part IAction Adventure | PS5 · PC | No | Yes | 15–25h platinum route | |
| The Last of Us Part II RemasteredAction Adventure | PS5 | No | Yes | 25–40h platinum route | |
| Resident Evil 4Survival Horror | PS5 · PS4 · Xbox Series +1 | Yes | Yes | 50–70h platinum route | |
| Resident Evil VillageSurvival Horror | PS5 · PS4 · Xbox Series +3 | Yes | Yes | 25–40h platinum route | |
| Silent Hill 2Survival Horror | PS5 · PC | Yes | Yes | 25–40h platinum route | |
| Dead SpaceSurvival Horror | PS5 · Xbox Series · PC | Yes | Yes | 30–40h platinum route | |
| Alan Wake 2Survival Horror | PS5 · Xbox Series · PC | Yes | Yes | 20–35h platinum route | |
| Dishonored 2Stealth / Action | PS4 · Xbox One · PC | Yes | Yes | 30–50h | |
| PreyImmersive Sim | PS4 · Xbox One · PC | Yes | Yes | 40–60h | |
| BioShock RemasteredFPS | PS4 · Xbox One · Switch +1 | Yes | Yes | 20–30h | |
| Gears 5Third-person Shooter | Xbox Series · Xbox One · PC | No | Yes | 80–120h | |
| Super Smash Bros. UltimateFighting | Switch | No | Yes | 80–120h | |
| Fire Emblem: Three HousesStrategy RPG | Switch | Yes | Yes | 80–200h | |
| Xenoblade Chronicles 3JRPG | Switch | No | Yes | 100–150h | |
| Dragon's Dogma 2Action RPG | PS5 · Xbox Series · PC | Yes | Yes | 60–100h | |
| Nioh 2Action RPG | PS5 · PS4 · PC | No | Yes | 80–120h | |
| Wo Long: Fallen DynastyAction RPG | PS5 · PS4 · Xbox Series +2 | No | Yes | 60–90h | |
| Lies of PAction RPG | PS5 · PS4 · Xbox Series +2 | Yes | Yes | 60–90h |